It’s difficult to know what I made of this book. The premise seemed right up my street, I was really intrigued to see how Gaiman would pull off this whole ‘Gods walking among us’ thing. I’m fascinated by mythology anyway so couldn’t wait to get stuck in, and I have to say I thoroughly enjoyed the first half or so, and to be fair I did enjoy the whole thing, I spent the last two days reading the the final 300 pages (a feat usually only my favourite books can make me accomplish) so it definitely kept me captivated.
When I first started reading the book I was really excited, I kept thinking in the back of my mind ‘Ooooh this could be five star worthy!’ (a bad habit I’ve picked up since using Goodreads regularly), I couldn’t wait to see how all the dots joined together. However I thought somewhere along the line, probably at some point during the lakeside saga which seemed to stretch on for ages with not a huge amount of plot progression, Gaiman lost his way a bit.
I mean conceptually the book was brilliant, really well researched – I was constantly googling the references to the Gods I didn’t know and reading up more on those I did – and as I’ve mentioned before in my review of The Ocean At The End of the Lane, Gaiman’s imagination is brilliant, he has a unique ability to create a believable fantastic reality that makes our own world seem that slight bit more magical.
The problem was I just kept caring less and less about what happened to the characters as the book went on.(view spoiler) A fair few of the characters who I found the most interesting were underdeveloped and had virtually no significance to the story line (Sam Black Crow comes to mind?).
The highlights for me were some of the short interludes, dream sequences and the development of the God characters in general:
I loved how Thoth and Anubis were portrayed as solemn, wise (and surprisingly friendly) funeral workers; I loved Mama-ji’s cranky old lady/god of death and war persona; I thought the ‘mystery money-god’ from the middle chapters (view spoiler)was eerily mysterious; and I thought Shadows hallucinatory conversation with (view spoiler) while he was hung up on the world tree was inspired. However, I’ve got to say, it was slightly disappointing not to see any of the Greek pantheon in there, especially considering they have such well known personalities, it would be great to see how Gaiman portrayed Zues, Dionysus or Apollo.
I can see why people really love Gaiman and I can see why people were thoroughly disappointed with American Gods, but I’m undoubtedly closer to the love side. So overall, for me, this book is definitely worth reading, it gets a solid 4 stars. My only qualm was that I think it had so much potential and didn’t quite live up to it. However, saying that, if you enjoy mythology, urban fantasy or just want a big book to get really stuck into, I’d definitely recommend American Gods.